"Left-wing feminists have a hard time dealing with strong, successful conservative women in politics such as Margaret Thatcher," writes Kathy Young at the Wall Street Journal editorial page.

Sarah Palin seems to have truly unhinged more than a few, eliciting a stream of vicious, often misogynist invective ... You'd think that, whether or not they agree with her politics, feminists would at least applaud Mrs. Palin as a living example of one of their core principles: a woman's right to have a career and a family. Yet some feminists unabashedly suggest that her decision to seek the vice presidency makes her a bad and selfish mother. Others argue that she is bad for working mothers because she's just too good at having it all.

Ann Althouse thinks this raises a larger question: Who owns "feminism"? She writes:

There was a time - I was there - back in the 80s and early 90s, when feminists would speak of "feminisms" and were always promoting some new version of feminism that, we'd argue, was better than the last. We were way out in front of the liberal feminists. So it seemed, and we duly disparaged them - from the left.

Those were heady times. But in recent years, feminism has been dominated by Democratic Party devotees who act like they own feminism, as if theirs was the only feminism - as if they could dictate that all women should vote Democratic.

Perversely, this conventional Democratic Party feminism took over after Bill Clinton made it rather obvious that within the Democratic Party, the party's interests would necessarily supervene women's interests. The feminism of the last dozen years has been a dull, uninspired argument for keeping Democratic politicians in power.

But feminism is something that transcends party politics. Women have interests that the parties should have to compete for. I want a vivid debate about what is good for women. Sarah Palin represents one argument, and her feminism will require Democrats to improve their argument and not take women for granted. Sarah Palin brings feminism to a lot of people who've been scorning feminism - because feminism has seemed like a strand of Democratic party politics.

This is great for feminism.

How many feminists will agree?



By Tobin Harshaw, The New York Times, September 15, 2008